Nordic model, Trump and the Responsibility of Intellectuals

Informações recentes no universo dos bolseiros. Notícias da imprensa sobre ciência são também bem-vindas.
Responder
Torgal
cientista sempre presente
cientista sempre presente
Mensagens: 1259
Registado: quarta dez 09, 2015 8:17 am
University/ Institute: Minho

Nordic model, Trump and the Responsibility of Intellectuals

Mensagem por Torgal » sexta mar 23, 2018 6:59 am

“The market is a useful servant, but an intolerable master”
https://www.socialeurope.eu/what-can-we ... rdic-model

The citation above was taken from the text In the link above that has an interesting article by Jón Baldvin Hannibalsson where he says not so nice things on the casino capitalism and on the great recession that US has exported to the rest of the world but says interesting things about the Nordic model. And speaking about very recent excellent Nordic practices Facebook just got backlisted by the biggest bank on the Nordic region https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles ... tment-unit

Still speaking of US and on market its very interesting that US just sold 12,5 billion in weapons to Saudi Arabia making US by far the biggest war exporter in the world https://www.independent.co.uk/news/worl ... 65821.HTML

It almost seems that the problems that Mr. Trump have with some dictators in the third world relate only to the fact that they have not yet visit the White House with a 12 billion check to buy missiles and other military weapons. Of course its some how highly hypocritical that the same Mr. Trump who sees the war business as a very lovely one just said 2 days ago that the drug business is a very ugly one and also that drug dealers should deserve the dead penalty. Does it make any sense that selling weapons (including Slam-Er missiles, Harpoon block missiles and AGM-158 missiles) is a legitimate and highly respectful business while selling drugs is a serious crime ? Probably the drug dealers in America should dedicate to the weapon selling business instead !

What has that to do with Academia ? Everything. In the end of the email below Noam Chomsky explains why. Even because if nothing pushes us back to our tribal past more than WAR then the most important mission of universities is not produce knowledge and patents (that a lot of corporate business already do in a more efficient way) but to contribute to PEACE.

_____________________________________________________________________
De: F. Pacheco Torgal
Enviado: 11 de Outubro de 2017 6:16
Assunto: Courage as an academic value of paramount importance

Although some of its books already receive several thousand citations on scholar google, and although he is more scholar material than thousands of PhD academics the fact is that Alain de Botton is not an academic. Nevertheless, probably he have done more than several thousand scholars have done in helping the transition of our society into a type 1 civilization. In a very insightful presentation he said:

“In the middle ages, in England when you met a very poor person that person would be described as an unfortunate, literally someone who has not been blessed by fortune, an unfortunate. Nowadays, particularly in the United States if you met someone in the bottom of society they may unkindly be described as a loser. There´s a real difference between an unfortunate and a loser and that shows 400 years of evolution in society”

It was not by chance that he mention the United States because it is in fact a country addicted on the successful narrative. A country in which at least in electoral terms literally "the winner takes it all". A country whose academia has indeed achieved a lot of successes, Nobel prizes not being one of those because so far US does not even get to enter the Top 10, US have won 1.1 Nobel prizes/million of population ranking below Switzerland and Sweden that have 3,1, Denmark 2,8, Norway 2,5, Austria 2,4, UK 1.9, Ireland 1.7, Israel 1.4, Germany and Hungary 1.3 and Netherlands that has 1.2. Still a place in which US ranks the first is in the number of retracted papers due to falsification/fabrication of data. According to Retraction Watch US has more of those trash papers than the number of similar papers with affiliation of China, Japan, Germany and UK combined.

But probably the worst failure of US academia is the failure to enlighten at least the US citizens that received a bachelor degree about the danger of a creating an extremely unequal society. US academia was not even able to show how absurd is the fact that a country of the first world has its rules on gun control dictated by a gun association. Back in the old days it was some how much more simpler to carry on such message. Now it is much more difficult because IA based platforms find what consumers want to hear/read in order to deliver exactly the news they want to her/read. No surprise then that almost 75% of US Americans get their news from Facebook, where the most popular source is the xenophobic, misogynist, alt-right Breitbart.

Although tenure has come as a way to defend the freedom of ideas the truth is that academia is full of tenured cowards. Fortunately, where there´s a tenured coward there´s also a courageous one and back in 1967, the year I was born, Noam Chomsky was courageous enough to author an essay entitled “The responsibility of Intellectualshttps://chomsky.info/19670223/ in which he attacked those that were subservient to US Government involved in the Vietnam war, special the social scientists like the historian Arthur Schlesinger. Obviously today it is much more different to be a courageous tenure academic in the universities of Western countries or to be on in China where they say that scientists who falsified data can even face dead penalty https://www.nature.com/articles/n-12286656and that gives us some important clues about what should be the business of tenured academics in the universities of Western countries.

They should have the courage to help the transition of the society where are in towards a type 1 civilization. They should have the courage to stop politicians to shrink universities budget almost into zero. They should have the courage to stop politicians to try to turn academics into sheeps like Mr Trump is been trying to do in US. They should have the courage to stand against the unethical research agendas of transnational corporate interests. https://www.alternet.org/investigations ... and-fossil

Responder